My In-Laws Are Furious I Don't Separate The Kids' Toys By Who They Were Gifted To
My wife and I have a three year old daughter and two year old son. I'll call them Dee and Sam for brevity. My in-laws often send us stuff for the kids, and it is usually addressed to Sam. I ignore this, as the kids are so close in age (11 months) and are at similar developmental stages. I never put much thought into why Sam's name is usually on the packages. Whenever they send a toy, it just goes in the play room, and the kids don't have individual toys, unless you count the stuffed animals they sleep with. My wife initially wanted to divide the toys into different chests for each kid. I said that didn't make sense, and it makes cleaning and organizing the room take longer. When I pick up the playroom, I organize the toys by type, and that makes them fit into less space and makes it impossible to forget what goes where, so things are easier to find. My wife admitted I was right, so that's how we've been doing things for a while. Today my in-laws were visiting and saw Dee playing with a toy. My mother in law asked why Dee had Sam's toy. I said we don't split the toys up like that. None of the toys are Sam's or Dee's. All the toys belong to Sam and Dee. My mother in law was upset, because she picked that toy out specifically for Sam. I just sort of shrugged. It's a plastic frog; there's nothing special about it. Father in law asked if I did that with everything they sent, and I said most things, but the kids do have their special stuffed animals they sleep with. Both were upset and started arguing with my wife in their language way too fast for me to keep up with, but it basically amounted to me being an ungrateful and rude asshole. Then they left. My wife said going forward we should keep toys bought for Sam separate, because it upsets her parents that the toys are communal. I said I wasn't okay with that. If we do that, we'd have to buy more stuff for Dee and less for Sam for them to have an equal number of toys. That would make Sam think we like him less than Dee and Dee think her grandparents like her less than Sam. I said if her parents aren't okay with that, they shouldn't send stuff. Now things are really tense. With her and her parents both mad at me, I'm questioning if I'm being a stubborn ass.
